Enter Mind's Eye. You will see, there is something on the pier.
Go outside, back on the pier and enter the rift.
The Rift Vision and Conclusion
There are 3 glowing blobs. 2 on the pier and one on the ship.
Go to them to reveal them.
Select the one on the ship first
Then select the axe fight on the pier.
Then select the one with the gun.
- Events on the Titania
- The wounded sailor (Mind Palace)
In the Mind Palace, combine The wounded sailor <-> Sanders has fled
This gives you another evidence:
- Wounded Sanders
All Evidence Collected